Taking Back Sunday - Tell All Your Friends (2002)

The Moment:

Cute Without The ‘E’ (obviously)

The Memory:

Listen, it’s not their best of the three albums I’ve listened to religiously.

In all honesty, it would probably rank last.

But remember in Brooklyn Nine-Nine when Peralta infiltrates the mob and says, “In the mafia, once you Joel together, you're bonded for life”?

That was us with Cute Without The ‘E’.